• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
South Asian Network

South Asian Network

JOIN OUR E-MAIL LIST DONATEEXIT
  • About
    • Mission & Vision
    • Our History
    • Our People
    • Impact Stories
    • Partners & Allies
    • Funders & Supporters
  • Programs & Services
    • AWAZ: Voices Against Violence
    • CHAI: Community Health Action Initiative
    • CCE: Citizenship & Civic Engagement
    • EMH: Emotional & Mental Health
    • REQUEST A SERVICE
  • Resources
  • Media
    • Blog
    • In the News
    • Press Contacts
    • Newsletters
    • Gallery
  • Calendar
  • Engage
    • REQUEST A SERVICE
    • Donate
    • Contact Us
    • Work with Us
    • Volunteer

The Parallels in our Freedom

March 1, 2022 by South Asian Network

BY CYNTHIA CHOCKALINGAM, CIVIL RIGHTS UNIT INTERN AT SAN

When I was—probably—around 10 years old, I learned at Chinmaya Mission—a Hindu Sunday School system—that when I walk around with scissors, the blade should be facing myself so no one else is at risk. We learned of self-sacrifice and valuing others; an innocent person should not suffer for the mistakes of others. But what about when they are not just an innocent person? Even before India’s fight for independence from the British, Black Americans were already fighting for freedom from the oppression they still face. Both conversations alike stress the importance of nonviolence from Mahatma Gandhi to Martin Luther King Jr. However, these conversations fail to include the importance of violence and nonviolence working side-by-side. At Black Lives Matter’s peak during the summer of 2020, many South Asians jumped to the side of white Americans in chastising the entire movement for the violence of some. Just as during the initial civil rights movement and the more recent Black Lives Matter movement—both of which are ongoing, South Asia’s fight for independence from Britain involved both civil disobedience and violence. 

India’s vision for independence began in 1857 with the rebellion uprising, which was later referred to as the First War of Independence. India itself learned that staying peaceful and moderate with no force did not lead to change. Gopal Krishna Gokhale, Congress President as of 1905 and one of Gandhi’s mentors, initially opposed what he called “extremists” like Bal Gangadhar Tilak, an early member of Congress who gained support in the 1890s. Tilak then spent the following decades cooling down towards Gokhale’s more “moderate” views. However, they soon learned this led India nowhere. Even when India greatly supported Britain during World War I, India was not granted any further autonomy. 

Understanding the fight for independence through key figures Bhagat Singh and Subhas Chandra Bose helps grasp the role violence played in India’s fight for independence. Born in 1907 to a Sikh family in modern Pakistan, Bhagat Singh was born into the fight for independence; when he was born, his father was in jail for political agitation. His father was a supporter of Gandhi, so Singh fell into this non-violent crusade, but in college, he came to believe armed conflict was the only way to political freedom. 

In April of 1929, he and his colleague—Batukeshwar Dutt—bombed the Legislative Assembly in Delhi to scare, not kill, as a result of the Public Safety Bill. After being arrested, he used the courtroom as a way to spread his political beliefs—rather than defend himself—so he was sentenced to life in prison. While investigating, Singh was connected to an earlier killing of Officer Saunders, so Singh was sentenced to death and hung. While he died at age 23, his life and actions became inspiration for many to come. 

Like Singh, Subhas Chandra Bose was a controversial figure, yet, also like Singh, he was extremely significant. While he was initially a supporter of Gandhi, he became more critical of his “less confrontational approach toward independence.” Leaving India in 1941, he travelled seeking Indian support for a forceful fight against the British. He appealed to Japan, receiving military support to take back to India. While he and his new crew were forced to retreat and he then died—which is rumored to be caused by a plane crash over Taiwan but is unconfirmed—he opened much of India and the government’s eyes to the hits they could make to the British forces. He was integral to forming the liberation army identity of the Indian National Army, and he became an inspiration for the independence movement. 

The Civil Rights Movement in America was fundamentally about freedom. Malcom X articulated that the center of this movement was identity, integrity, and independence. His philosophy was for Black Americans to protect themselves from white aggressors “by any means necessary.” Even Martin Luther King, Jr stated that Malcolm X “had the great ability to put his finger on the existence and root of the problem.” Nonetheless, the importance of non-violence cannot be undermined. They have been critical in both independence movements, both that of India and Black Americans. However, South Asians should not misrepresent our own history: it was not that purely of non-violence and success did not come from non-violence alone. Instead, we should understand this violence and force comes from a place of suffering; violent and non-violent actions together is what made India’s freedom possible. As Black History Month comes to an end, that does not mean it is time for everyone to go back to turning a blind eye to Black people’s suffering. Conversations of discrimination and inequality should continue afterwards for the rest of the year, even—and especially—in South Asian spaces. Black Americans should not be expected to keep sitting back waiting for this nation to treat them as equals. 

Additional reading

https://www.independent.co.uk/world/the-forgotten-violence-that-helped-india-break-free-from-colonial-rule-a7409066.html

BACK TO OUR PEOPLE BACK TO BLOG BACK TO OUR STORIES

Footer

South Asian Network

southasiannetwork

Medi-Cal update! We can help you begin your applic Medi-Cal update! We can help you begin your application today, reach out to us!

#medical #socal #healthcare #healthcareforallnow #california #southasian #nonprofit #socalnonprofit #applicationassistence
Some food for thought this Independence Day. 🇺🇸 #independenceday #july4th #happyindependenceday
Pictures from SAN's Pride Rally 2022! 🏳️‍🌈Pioneer Blvd was louder, brighter and definitely prouder as we were joined by @saharacares , @satrangsocal & @cpaforg along with other members of our community in promoting the visibility of the South Asian queer community. A big thank you to everyone who came out to make this possible. #punintended #queerrightsarehumanrights #southasiannetwork #nonprofit #southerncalifornia #pride #pridemonth
Final Pride Spotlight for this year! We hope you w Final Pride Spotlight for this year! We hope you were able to find comfort in representation and learn something new about our spotlighted LGBTQ members.

#representationmatters #bisexualrepresentaion #Pride #pride2022 #nonprofit #southasian #southasianrepresentaion
06.24.2022 #roevwade #abortionrights #humanrights 06.24.2022 #roevwade #abortionrights #humanrights #advocacy #nonprofitorganization #southerncalifornia #southasiannetwork
The weekend was colorful & vibrant for SAN as we s The weekend was colorful & vibrant for SAN as we spent great quality time with our community! 

We spent Friday prayers at The Islamic Center of Santa Ana @icsa.youth & on Saturday, we tabled at Hot Person Summer Event, a fashion-forward resource fair and gender-affirming clothing swap centered on addressing the needs of LGBTQ+ BIPOC community members in Orange County, held by @vietrainbowoc 

On the same day, SAN’s EMH Unit conducted a workshop on Intergenerational Trauma & Self Defense at the Boys & Girls Club of West San Gabriel Valley, hosted by @cpaforg. Swipe to see us do what we do best: Spread awareness and reaffirm our presence and support for our community. 🤝 #communityservice #socialservice #nonprofitorganization #southerncalifornia #southasiannetwork #socal
Our team is growing! Visit the link in our bio to Our team is growing! Visit the link in our bio to find the full JD or contact us to learn more. 

#southasian #jobopening #nonprofitcareer #socal #nonprofit #domesticviolencesupport #sexualassaultsupport #newjob #hiring
Today we commemorate the emancipation of African A Today we commemorate the emancipation of African American slaves across the United States. The celebration began in 1865 in Texas and is now recognized as a federal holiday. We must take this opportunity to recognize the Black activists that paved the way for other communities of color in this country. SAN stands strong in solidarity during this continuous fight against inequality and the racism that still pollutes our society today.

#juneteenth #juneteenth2022 #blm #southasian #solidarity #activism #nonprofit #socal #california
Join us for our 2022 Pride Celebration! March star Join us for our 2022 Pride Celebration! March starts at 130, Speakers at 230 & lunch at 3! If you have any questions please contact Tanya at (562) 403-0488 ext. 217

#pride #lgbtqpride #pride2022 #southasianpride #representation #nonprofit #southerncalifornia #california #artesia #cerritos #SouthAsianLGBTQ
Looking into the roots of these problems. It's tim Looking into the roots of these problems. It's time to start having these important conversations.

Post 2/2

#pridemonth #pride2022 #southasian #lgbtq #immigrants #southasiannonprofit #socal #california
Pride Spotlight continues! This weeks spotlight is Pride Spotlight continues! This weeks spotlight is on Urvashi Vaid who recently passed this year, leaving behind a great legacy of activism and pride. 

#pride🌈  #southasian #pride2022 #gayrepresentation #nonprofit
Let's talk about representation in the LGBTQ+ comm Let's talk about representation in the LGBTQ+ community.

Post 1/2

#southasian #lgbtq #pridemonth #pride2022 #southasianrepresentation #representaionmatters #southasiannonprofit #southerncalifornia
Our Civil Rights Unit (CRU) Program Assistant Shak Our Civil Rights Unit (CRU) Program Assistant Shakuntala Chugani conducting Round 2 of ESL Classes to help our community prepare for their naturalization interviews! 🇺🇸 If you or anyone you know, needs assistance with regards to citizenship applications or prepping for your interview, reach out to SAN for help at every step on the way! #communityfirst #esl #uscitizenship #southasiannetwork #southerncalifornia #nonprofit
Week 2 of Pride Spotlight! Who's seen @nbcthegoodp Week 2 of Pride Spotlight! Who's seen @nbcthegoodplace :)?

#pride🌈 #pride2022 #bisexualpride #southasian #southasianrepresentation #representationmatters
This past weekend, SAN staff visited three Gurdwar This past weekend, SAN staff visited three Gurdwaras in LA Count including @khalsacarefoundation and @nanak_sadan_sikh_temple to help our community members with Covered California & Citizenship queries, along with talking to them about all of SAN’s services. We hope to reach as many South Asians as we can! #nonprofitorganization #southerncalifornia #southasiannetwork #socal #communityservice

Copyright © 2022 · SOUTH ASIAN NETWORK

site credits